Carbon Fluxes in the Arctic Headwater Streams

Grade Level: 9-12

Summary

This multi-part lesson introduces key concepts related to Arctic carbon fluxes, including permafrost’s role, headwater streams’ importance, and the significance of this topic in long term ecological change research. It also  includes a “Meet the Scientist” segment and an activity where students analyze and graph hydrological data from different Arctic seasons (snowmelt, Arctic summer, and late season). To demonstrate their understanding students are asked to create a visual representation that captures the key concepts about carbon fluxes in Arctic headwater streams. This resource offers a blend of theoretical knowledge and practical application, aiming to engage students in understanding complex environmental processes while developing their analytical and scientific reasoning abilities.

Materials and Preparation

  • Printed or digital copies of the student worksheet 
  • Graphing tools – Students will need access to either:
    • Graphing software (Google Sheets, Excel, or another online graphing tool)
    • Graph paper and colored pencils/pens if graphs are done by hand
  • Rulers and pencils – For accurate graph scaling (if using graph paper) and sketching Arctic landscape.
  • Internet access – If students watch the video about Macall Hock’s research.
  • Data sets – The data will be both embedded and available to print
  • Colored markers/pencils – These are used to create graphs and visualize the carbon flux sketch.

Optional:

  • Science Notebooks or Lab Journals – For annotating concepts, developing hypotheses, answering questions, and taking notes.
  • Computers/Tablets – If using digital graphing tools or watching the suggested video from the document.

Learning Objectives

Objective #1
Explain the role of Arctic streams in transporting carbon and how changes in the Arctic (like permafrost thawing) create feedback loops that affect the global climate system.
Objective #2
Accurately graph data, identify trends, and relate changes in environmental variables to carbon dynamics in Arctic headwater streams.
Objective #3
Articulate how scientific findings from the Arctic can inform global policies and actions related to climate change mitigation and environmental protection, bridging local research with global impacts.

Opening Activity

Start with an engaging question: “How can the Arctic, one of the coldest places on Earth, influence global climate change? How does this landscape affect us all?”

Show a short video clip or series of images about the Arctic’s rapid environmental changes due to global warming. Highlight permafrost thaw and its role in carbon emissions.

Ask students to brainstorm how carbon in the Arctic could affect the rest of the world. Write their ideas on the board.


Activity Overview

Use the instructors Guide for full activity detail:

Part I introduces key concepts related to Arctic carbon fluxes, including permafrost’s role, headwater streams’ importance, and the significance of this topic in climate change research. It includes background information, a section on stream classification using Strahler numbers, and challenge questions to encourage critical thinking. This section also features a “Meet the Scientist” segment, highlighting the work of researcher Macall Hock.

Part II consists of a lab activity where students analyze hydrological data from different Arctic seasons (snowmelt, Arctic summer, and late season). Students are asked to graph data on stream flow rates, photosynthetic light levels, and temperature fluctuations. They then interpret this data to understand how these factors influence carbon fluxes in Arctic streams. The lab concludes with a structured analysis and a CER (Claim, Evidence, Reasoning) exercise to reinforce scientific thinking and writing skills.

Part III  In this part of the lesson, students are asked to create a visual representation that captures the key concepts about carbon fluxes in Arctic headwater streams. The goal is for students to demonstrate their understanding of the complex processes occurring in these unique environments. The sketch is meant to be a conceptual drawing, not a scientific illustration. Students should focus on conveying the main ideas about carbon fluxes in an informative and visually appealing way.


Reflection

Ask students to reflect on the following questions:

  • “How does your sketch help explain carbon fluxes in the Arctic ecosystem?”
  • “What were the biggest challenges you faced in representing the complex interactions in the system?”
  • “How might climate change further affect these carbon fluxes?”

  Conduct a class discussion, or have students write a brief reflection in their notebooks.

Exit Tickets: 

  • “What are the most important things you learned about carbon fluxes in Arctic headwater streams?”
  • “How has your understanding of the Arctic’s role in global climate change changed?”
  • “What challenges did you face during the graphing or sketching activities, and how did you overcome them?”
  • “How do you think you could apply the skills you learned in this lesson to real-world environmental issues?”
  • “What’s one key concept you learned today, and how does it connect to the real world?”

Optional Gallery Walk:

  • Organize a gallery walk where students display their sketches around the room and observe others’ work. Encourage students to leave comments or questions on sticky notes.

Supporting Documents

Assessment of Learning Objectives:

You can assess students based on their:

  • Graphs and data interpretations
  • CER writing and reasoning
  • Carbon flux sketches
  • Participation in discussions and group work

Use the rubrics provided in the handout to evaluate scientific accuracy, labeling, and presentation.


Graphing Activity
: Review the students’ graphs for accuracy. Did they correctly interpret the data on stream flow, photosynthetic light, and temperature across the seasons? Check for proper scaling, labeling, and the use of different colors for each season.

CER Statements: Assess students’ CER statements to determine whether they can make a strong claim based on evidence from their data analysis. Evaluate how well they connect their evidence to the claim using scientific reasoning.

Carbon Flux Sketches: Use the rubric in the PDF to assess the accuracy and detail of the students’ sketches. Do the sketches correctly understand carbon movement in Arctic headwater streams? Are the seasonal variations and feedback loops represented?


  • All the material was gathered from interviews/field work with Macall Hock at San Diego State University.
  • The supplemental video was from the United Nations YouTube channel
  • A special thanks go to the patient, intelligent, and generous Macall Hock, whose vast knowledge and expertise were instrumental in creating this lesson. Her dedication and hard work are truly inspiring, and I am incredibly grateful for the opportunity to collaborate with her!

Additional Standards Information:

Texas Essential Knowledge and Skills (TEKS) – 9-12

  1. Environmental Systems (112.37)

   – (2)(E): Plan and implement comparative and descriptive investigations by making observations, asking well-defined questions, and using appropriate equipment and technology.

   – (7)(A): Analyze and describe the effects of natural events such as fires, hurricanes, or volcanic eruptions on ecosystems.

   – (9)(C): Analyze the global carbon cycle and the roles of living organisms in the cycling of matter.

   – (11)(A): Analyze how environmental changes affect ecosystems over time.

  1. Earth and Space Science (112.36)

   – (10)(A): Analyze the carbon, nitrogen, water, and phosphorus cycles and explain the consequences of disrupting these cycles.

   – (11)(C): Predict how the introduction or removal of an organism in an ecosystem impacts the cycling of matter.

   – (12)(B): Evaluate the role of energy, water, and carbon cycles in maintaining climate stability.

  1. Biology (112.34)

   – (12)(F): Describe how environmental change can impact ecosystem stability.

Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS)

  1. HS-ESS2-2: Analyze geoscience data to make the claim that one change to Earth’s surface can create feedbacks that cause changes to other Earth systems.
  2. HS-ESS2-6: Develop a quantitative model to describe the cycling of carbon among the hydrosphere, atmosphere, geosphere, and biosphere.
  3. HS-ESS3-5: Analyze geoscience data and the results of global climate models to make an evidence-based forecast of the current rate of global or regional climate change and associated future impacts.
  4. HS-LS2-5: Develop a model to illustrate the role of photosynthesis and cellular respiration in the cycling of carbon among the biosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere, and geosphere.
  5. HS-LS2-7: Design, evaluate, and refine a solution for reducing the impacts of human activities on the environment and biodiversity.
  6. HS-LS2-4: Use mathematical representations to support claims for the cycling of matter and flow of energy among organisms in an ecosystem.

 STEM Standards

  1. Analyzing and Interpreting Data (Science & Engineering Practice – NGSS aligned)

   – Students analyze hydrological and temperature data, graph it, and draw conclusions, aligning with STEM data analysis and critical thinking competencies.

  1. Crosscutting Concepts: Energy and Matter (NGSS aligned)

   – Students observe how carbon moves through the Arctic ecosystem, reflecting STEM standards related to the flow of energy and matter.

  1. Computational Thinking (ISTE Standards for Students)

   – Students use technology (e.g., Excel or Google Sheets) to create graphs, process data, and draw conclusions from scientific data.

Environmental Literacy Standards

  1. Framework for K-12 Science Education (National Research Council)

   – Energy in the Earth System: The lesson ties into broader environmental literacy by focusing on how carbon fluxes in the Arctic contribute to global energy flow and climate change impacts.

  1. North American Association for Environmental Education (NAAEE) Guidelines for Excellence:

   – Strand 2.2: Environmental Processes and Systems: Focus on understanding ecological concepts, the carbon cycle, and human impacts on the environment.

   – Strand 3.1: Skills for Analyzing and Investigating Environmental Issues: Students interpret data and analyze environmental changes.

Career and Technical Education (CTE) Standards

  1. Environmental Science and Technology Pathway:

   – This lesson prepares students for careers related to environmental science by teaching data collection, analysis, and interpretation, all critical for future work in climate research and environmental conservation.

 Tribal and Ethnic Studies (Cultural Awareness)

   – The inclusion of Arctic research connects to Indigenous populations in the Arctic regions, which are often profoundly affected by climate change, offering an opportunity to integrate discussions on the impacts of environmental changes on traditional cultures and livelihoods.


Standards:

Science Practice 2
Developing and using models
Science Practice 4
Analyzing and interpreting data
Science Practice 6
Constructing explanations (for science) and designing solutions (for engineering)
Science Practice 7
Engaging in argument from evidence
Crosscutting Concept 2
Cause and effect: mechanism and explanation
Crosscutting Concept 5
Energy and matter: flows, cycles and conservation
LS 2
Ecosystems: interactions, energy, and dynamics
ESS 2
Earth’s system

Polar Literacy Principles:

1
Location: The Arctic and Antarctic Regions are unique because of their location on Earth
3
Circulation: Polar Regions play a central role in regulating Earth’s weather and climate
5
Climate: The Poles are experiencing the effects of climate change at an accelerating rate
7

New technologies, sensors and tools — as well as new applications of existing technologies — are expanding scientists’ abilities to study the land, ice, ocean, atmosphere and living creatures of the Polar Regions.

Resource Developed By

To learn more about this project

View Project